Recommended Video
How perfect is perfect, really? Everybody’s got an idea—some small and discreet, others all-out and ‘look at me’ from afar. A pragmatist will tell you that it’s the thought that counts (believe them), but an engagement ring should also feel like it belongs on your hand tomorrow, next week, and forever. That said, does bigger always mean better? We ask jeweler Sofia Yulo, founder of her eponymous brand, to break down the anatomy of the perfect engagement ring.
RELATED: Motion & Restraint: Jewelry Trends at MEGA Ball 2025
Have you seen that one episode where Belly Conklin from The Summer I Turned Pretty got proposed to? It stirred chatter, and it wasn’t so much about the engagement itself, but about the ring that some thought was “too small.” Then, we remember Georgina Rodríguez’s and Lauren Sanchez’s that were so massive they made “sparkler” sound modest.
So, from one extreme to the other: Does size really matter?
“Not necessarily,” Yulo says. “You could have a 25-carat diamond full of inclusions that looks cloudy, but a well-cut one-carat (or even less) diamond with little to no inclusions can outshine it instantly.”
Quality comes first to Yulo, and it makes perfect sense. What good is a big stone when the meaning doesn’t match the gesture?
Part 1: The Thought
“It’s the story behind it,” Yulo tells us. “How did your partner choose it? Was it inspired by something personal you share, or a detail they remembered about your taste? Or was it a passed-down heirloom? I think a ring becomes truly perfect when it reflects thoughtfulness and intention.”
Take 2017: Harry, Meghan, and that three-stone engagement ring. How could it have been just jewelry in the presence of borrowed diamonds from Princess Diana’s collection? A story like that is worn beautifully on the finger, but even better felt in the heart.
Part 2: The Clarity
It talks of the purity of a diamond, how free it is from tiny imperfections on the surface or within. On the scale, Flawless (F) diamonds are completely clean under 10x magnification, while Included 3 (I3) stones show heavy inclusions visible to the naked eye.
“As someone who studied diamond and gemstone grading, I can’t help but look at the stone’s clarity. For me, a ring becomes truly impressive when it features stones with great clarity,” Yulo shares.
Take Zendaya’s: near-colorless, likely of VVS clarity, valued at around $400,000. It proves the point: size can grab attention, but clarity seduces it. A smaller, perfect stone can outshine a massive one every time.
Part 3: The Wearer
So, there’s the thought, size, and clarity, but a ring only comes alive on the hand it was meant for. “Every hand is unique,” Yulo says, “so it’s not just about choosing your favorite shape.”
“It’s also about finding a design that flatters your fingers and feels balanced, from the proportions of the stone to the shape of the setting and the thickness of the band.”
It’s like dating: what you want and what actually works don’t always match. You can lust over a round cut, but on short fingers, it can read a little stubby. Ovals, too, are stunning, but on long, slender hands, they risk veering into spider-leg territory. Balance is everything.
We think of Selena Gomez for this. Her marquise-shaped diamond, framed with yellow pavé shoulders, nails the sweetest spot: slender but not spindly, bold but not bulky.
Whether you’re reading this to plot hints for your partner, the partner researching for the perfect ring, or just looking to get your next Harry Winston, Cartier, or Sofa Yulo Fine Jewelry purchase, remember: the right one isn’t all carats, clarity, or cut. It’s chemistry. You’ll know when the right one fits.
Photos: ROYAL FAMILY INSIDER, ZENDAYA UPDATES, ALL ABOUT PHOEBE DYNEVOR (via X), SELENA GOMEZ, GEORGINA RODRÍGUEZ (via Instagram)
